Former New Rochelle Police Office Sentenced to 5 Years "Shock Probation" in Online Teen Sex Case

Time to read
2 minutes
Read so far

Former New Rochelle Police Office Sentenced to 5 Years "Shock Probation" in Online Teen Sex Case

July 10, 2013 - 22:01


Former New Rochelle Police Officer Matthew Melillo was sentenced to 5 years "shock probation" on charges related to Disseminating Indecent Material to a Minor, videos of himself in a sexual act. Melillo plead guilty in April to Attempted to Disseminating Indecent Material to a Minor, a class “E” Felony.

Melillo will have a sex offender hearing on September 17th.

Talk of the Sound broke the story of Melillo's arrest September 12, 2012.

At the time, New Rochelle City Manager Charles B. Strome told Talk of the Sound Melillo was suspended without pay for 30 days. Melillo is no longer employed by the City of New Rochelle.

Melillo was employed by the New Rochelle Police Department for eight years. He was employed as Community Service Officer from 2004 to 2010, and was employed as a Police Officer from July 2010 until soon after his arrest.

Melillo was one of five New Rochelle police officers to graduate from the Westchester Police Academy in December 2010.

Melillo was alleged to have transmitted videos of himself engaged in a sexual act to what he believed to be 15 year-old girl. The "girl" was an undercover criminal investigator working for the Westchester County District Attorney.

Matthew Melillo, 31, 475 North Avenue, New Rochelle, New York, was arraigned on a Felony Complaint charging him with one count of Attempted to Disseminating Indecent Material to a Minor, a class “E” Felony.

Between August 3rd, and August 29th, 2012, the defendant engaged an undercover investigator from the Westchester County District Attorneys Office in a series of “chat” conversations through the Internet.

Throughout the “chats” the undercover investigator made it clear that “she” was a fifteen year old girl.

During that period of time the defendant discussed various specific sexual acts in which he would engage the “fifteen year old girl.”

Additionally, the defendant sent a video he claimed to be of himself in a sexual situation while he was “chatting” with the fifteen year old.

The defendant was arrested by investigators from the Westchester County District Attorneys office.

Investigators from the District Attorney's office did not inform the City of New Rochelle or the New Rochelle Police Department of the investigation of one of their officers until Melillo was arrested. DA Investigators then went to NRPD headquarters to search Melillo's locker and checking computers.

According to the Stepinac alumni web site, Melillo graduated from Stepinac High School in 1998. He played football for the school.

Melillo is just the latest in a series of public employees alleged to have engaged in various sex crimes involving students and district employees: Marisa Anton (Librarian, New Rochelle High School), Patrick Clark (Electrician, Buildings & Grounds Department) Anthony Newman (Glazier, Buildings & Grounds Department), Donna Henry (New Rochelle School Security Guard), Leroy Manuel (New Rochelle School Security Guard), Robert McLean (New Rochelle School Security Guard), Kyle Figueroa (New Rochelle School Security Guard), Walter Hubbard (New Rochelle School Janitor).

In 2010, Jose Martinez plead guilty to repeatedly sexually assaulting a student in his office at Isaac E. Young Middle School. Despite promises to do so, the New Rochelle Board of Education never conducted an investigation into the Martinez case nor made the results public.

There are 4 Comments

This article says that Matthew Melillo resides at 475 North Ave, New Rochelle, NY.

That's the address of NR Police Department. Does Melillo live at the police station, or perhaps the city jail?

There is no Matthew Melillo registered to vote in New Rochelle.

Is a New Rochelle police officer required to live in New Rochelle, or in Westchester? Did Melillo lie about his residence to illegally get or keep his job?

Did Matthew Melillo lie to the authorities as to his home address? If he is on shock probation, it means to some extent having to be home, but where is his home?

Matthew Melillo's actual home address has to be reported and circulated because he is a convicted sexual pervert who is dangerous to children.

Robert Cox's picture

They gave out the address of the police HQ because he was a cop.

He lived in the East End but has since moved out of New Rochelle, reportedly to the Bronx.

Does being a disgraced former cop prevent his neighbors in the Bronx from being notified of his penal conviction of being a sexual predator?

Shouldn't his neighbors with children be notified of where he lives?

Robert Cox's picture


As noted in the article, there will be a hearing in September regarding the sexual predator law. Depending on how he is classified (based on likelihood of recidivism) he may or may not have to notify neighbors.